MtStH exists? Prove it. Shared experiences with other people? Prove they exist. You’re climbing it right now? No, your experience is that you’re climbing it right now, and your experience is not reality. Your experience and reality may or may not correlate; you could be a “brain in a jar” receiving inputs from something else entirely which produce in your consciousness the experience of climbing a mountain. You could be innumerable layers deep in a simulation.
Experience and reality are separate things. For practical purposes, behaving as though they correlate works, but they are distinct from one another.
Shared experiences with other people? Prove they exist.
See, this is where you lose me. When you’re out and about in the world, interacting with people, interfacing with reality, it’s not up to those individuals to prove to you that they exist prior to, during, or after your interactions with them. You don’t doubt the existence of your lunch before you eat your lunch; it is an objective fact that your lunch exists, hopefully, and if not, you are objectively hungry. Your body will suffer measurable physiological effects from your hunger. If you starve and die, it’s a fact that you are now dead.
Do you have evidence to back up the “brain in a jar” theory? Cuz we can talk about “could be’s” all day long, but what is measurable, consistent, and verifiable externally by everyone is what matters far more
Some people hallucinate that others exist all the time. Hell, I’ve done it. How can I know with 100% certainty that the people I see exist, and aren’t hallucinations?
All right, We’ll do it the other way.
MtStH exists? Prove it. Shared experiences with other people? Prove they exist. You’re climbing it right now? No, your experience is that you’re climbing it right now, and your experience is not reality. Your experience and reality may or may not correlate; you could be a “brain in a jar” receiving inputs from something else entirely which produce in your consciousness the experience of climbing a mountain. You could be innumerable layers deep in a simulation.
Experience and reality are separate things. For practical purposes, behaving as though they correlate works, but they are distinct from one another.
See, this is where you lose me. When you’re out and about in the world, interacting with people, interfacing with reality, it’s not up to those individuals to prove to you that they exist prior to, during, or after your interactions with them. You don’t doubt the existence of your lunch before you eat your lunch; it is an objective fact that your lunch exists, hopefully, and if not, you are objectively hungry. Your body will suffer measurable physiological effects from your hunger. If you starve and die, it’s a fact that you are now dead.
Do you have evidence to back up the “brain in a jar” theory? Cuz we can talk about “could be’s” all day long, but what is measurable, consistent, and verifiable externally by everyone is what matters far more
Some people hallucinate that others exist all the time. Hell, I’ve done it. How can I know with 100% certainty that the people I see exist, and aren’t hallucinations?