Because there isn’t any legitimate reason to turn away people seeking asylum or looking to immigrate. The issue with the process we have how intentionally slow and throttled it is. We can easily speed up the legalization process. Illegal immigration happens either from desperation or, most commonly, overstayed visas. Instead of treating this as a criminal act, we can simply have them begin the legalization process while staying in the country.
Even from an economic perspective immigrants are a benefit. However our intentional two-tier labor system is utilized by companies to hyperexploit illegal immigrants by threat of deportation. Legalization is critical to also institute labor protections. Along with unionization, this would also benefit American workers in those same industries with increased pay and benefits. Companies like to use the two-tier labor system to also justify lowering wages for the legal workers.
I tend to err on the side of the argument you’re on. I think we should have a far more robust visa system and path to citizenship, largely because we benefit from immigrants’ work to such a significant extent.
I don’t think it’ll ever happen though, for the same reason that we’ll never see legalized abortion in this country. Some issues are just way too easy for a political party to monetize. (And it’s legal for politicians to loan their campaigns money at 20% interest and then pocket those donations.)
There is an argument to be made for immigration disrupting the culture of border cities, but I think that’s more of an issue with illegal immigration as opposed to legal immigration, so to me, that’s just more fodder for the argument that we should have a more accessible path to citizenship.
I don’t think it’ll ever happen though, for the same reason that we’ll never see legalized abortion in this country
We need a party that serves the working class before a lot of these issues are able to gain traction. Unfortunately the vast majority of politicians are captured by corporate interests, and our system is designed to reward such.
There is an argument to be made for immigration disrupting the culture of border cities
I don’t think there is a good argument to be made for that honesty, the vast majority of people who think of immigrants as ‘disrupting culture’ seem to simply dislike diversity when you try to dig down at what exactly is being disrupted. I honestly think that’s more of an education issue. Where the expansion of public education, including college, would help the most. Especially with the legalization aspect you mentioned. Legalized immigrants would have their educational opportunities far improved, and it would also improve integration. Ultimately, integration is a generational thing, but public education can definitely improve it for everyone
Not like the brazen giant of Greek fame,
With conquering limbs astride from land to land;
Here at our sea-washed, sunset gates shall stand
A mighty woman with a torch, whose flame
Is the imprisoned lightning, and her name
Mother of Exiles. From her beacon-hand
Glows world-wide welcome; her mild eyes command
The air-bridged harbor that twin cities frame.
“Keep, ancient lands, your storied pomp!” cries she
With silent lips. “Give me your tired, your poor,
Your huddled masses yearning to breathe free,
The wretched refuse of your teeming shore.
Send these, the homeless, tempest-tost to me,
I lift my lamp beside the golden door!”
True, I fucking wish they went with an open border policy
Why is that?
(Not saying this to be sarcastic, genuinely curious about your POV.)
Because there isn’t any legitimate reason to turn away people seeking asylum or looking to immigrate. The issue with the process we have how intentionally slow and throttled it is. We can easily speed up the legalization process. Illegal immigration happens either from desperation or, most commonly, overstayed visas. Instead of treating this as a criminal act, we can simply have them begin the legalization process while staying in the country.
Even from an economic perspective immigrants are a benefit. However our intentional two-tier labor system is utilized by companies to hyperexploit illegal immigrants by threat of deportation. Legalization is critical to also institute labor protections. Along with unionization, this would also benefit American workers in those same industries with increased pay and benefits. Companies like to use the two-tier labor system to also justify lowering wages for the legal workers.
You make some good points, thank you.
I tend to err on the side of the argument you’re on. I think we should have a far more robust visa system and path to citizenship, largely because we benefit from immigrants’ work to such a significant extent.
I don’t think it’ll ever happen though, for the same reason that we’ll never see legalized abortion in this country. Some issues are just way too easy for a political party to monetize. (And it’s legal for politicians to loan their campaigns money at 20% interest and then pocket those donations.)
There is an argument to be made for immigration disrupting the culture of border cities, but I think that’s more of an issue with illegal immigration as opposed to legal immigration, so to me, that’s just more fodder for the argument that we should have a more accessible path to citizenship.
We need a party that serves the working class before a lot of these issues are able to gain traction. Unfortunately the vast majority of politicians are captured by corporate interests, and our system is designed to reward such.
I don’t think there is a good argument to be made for that honesty, the vast majority of people who think of immigrants as ‘disrupting culture’ seem to simply dislike diversity when you try to dig down at what exactly is being disrupted. I honestly think that’s more of an education issue. Where the expansion of public education, including college, would help the most. Especially with the legalization aspect you mentioned. Legalized immigrants would have their educational opportunities far improved, and it would also improve integration. Ultimately, integration is a generational thing, but public education can definitely improve it for everyone